See more of Utah Lighthouse Ministry on Facebook. Mormon Coffee. The lawsuit targeted the Tanners because their Utah Lighthouse Ministry's website posted pages from the Church's General Handbook of Instructions in violation of the copyright law. A Salt Lake City corporation name Intellectual Reserve, Inc. (IRI) owns the copyright and other intellectual property of the Mormon Church, so it is the plaintiff in the suit. The Utah Lighthouse Ministry (UTLM), an organization that publishes information critically analyzing the history and doctrines of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), sued Allen Wyatt, his company Discovery Computing, Inc. (DCI), the Foundation for Apologetic Information & Research (FAIR), and one of FAIR's directors, Scott Gordon. Utah Lighthouse Ministry v. Foundation for Apologetic Information & Research, 527 F. 3d 1045 (10th Cir. LAWSUIT AGAINST FAIR COMES TO A CLOSE. 2008). The Tanners' site didn't actually link to the pirated texts—it just posted the … 2008). at 1051-52. A federal judge has refused to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the legal copyright holder of LDS Church material against a couple who posted portions of a church procedures handbook on their ministry Web site. The couple founded Utah Lighthouse Ministries (UTLM) and sold books, newsletters and Internet materials that challenged LDS doctrines and practices. FIRM Foundation. at 1052. Utah Lighthouse Ministry (UTLM) appeals from a decision of the district court granting Defendants’ motion for summary judgment on UTLM’s claims of trademark infringement, unfair competition, and cybersquatting. The Tanners seem to be following what is becoming a regular pattern among some anti-Mormons: When you can’t win in the court of public opinion, try to silence your critics in a court of law. Religious Organization. decided December 6, 1999 . The Tanners, who run the Utah-based Utah Lighthouse Ministry, posted the GHI chapter on church discipline to their website in July 1999, to aid those trying to leave the LDS Church, and the Church sued to get the pages, and links to the GHI elsewhere, removed from the website. Mormonism Research Ministry. Later the same day they filed their lawsuit against the Ministry. Mormonism Research Ministry. Religious Organization. “The Lanham Act is intended ‘to protect the ability of consumers to distinguish among competing producers,’ not to prevent all unau-thorized uses.” Id. Forgot account? A look at a joyful anniversary celebration in June, held at the Tabernacle in Salt Lake City. Religious Organization. Utah Lighthouse Ministry v. This lawsuit by Utah Lighthouse ministries follows in the wake of earlier suits filed by Walter Martin against the LDS Church and Kurt Van Gordon against FARMS and SHIELDS. The Tanners operate the Utah Lighthouse Ministry Web site, to "document problems with the claims of Mormonism and compare LDS doctrines with Christianity," according to its home page. (See id., Ex. 2.) Utah Lighthouse Ministry, 75 F. Supp. due to resignations, and tens of thousands of others who get summarily excommunicated, like I was, for telling the truth about church history, as its true history becomes available via the internet on such websites as exmormon.com, mormonthink.com, and organizations like Utah Lighthouse Ministry. Religious Organization. Dear Sandra: I must admit that I was astonished when, on June 19th, your husband showed up and tossed me (and my friend) from your bookstore. UTLM filed suit against Allen Wyatt; his wife, Debra; their company, Discovery Computing Inc., based in Arizona; another organization called Foundation for Apologetic Information & Research (FAIR), a New York-based corporation; and its … Facts. Podcast. for Apologetic Info. 6.) They published 17 pages of the 160-page handbook on the Utah Lighthouse Ministry website. & Research , 527 F.3d 1045 (10th Cir. Utah Lighthouse Ministries, in federal court in Salt Lake City, Utah. See Utah Lighthouse Ministry v. Found. I. Utah Lighthouse Ministry's news page on lawsuit, Intellectual Reserve Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry Inc. Prestige Elite Communications Carl S. Kaplan at kaplanc@nytimes.com welcomes your … Related Pages. Jerald Dee Tanner (June 1, 1938 — October 1, 2006) was an American writer and researcher. Because the 2.) F.A.I.R., 527 F.3d 1045, 1050 (10th Cir. Religious Organization. Create New Account. After being directed by the court to remove the Handbook from its website, defendants posted a message on its website that informed users that the Handbook was online. Information about the recently ended lawsuit against FAIR by Sandra Tanner and Utah Lighthouse Ministry. The lawsuit pertains to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints' Church Handbook of Instructions. That section includes a chronology of the events related to this lawsuit. In what became a very controversial move, the Church also challenged the website's subsequent posting of links to other sites that contained the material. A judge in Salt Lake City ruled a Web site reportedly set up for The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research _ or FAIR _ was a … Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. 75 F.Supp. This matter is before the court on plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction. Unveiling Grace Book. Six more states have joined the lawsuit over a proposed Longview coal export dock to support Washington Gov. Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. | 75 F Supp 2d 1290 | December 06, 1999 | mrisch. In support of its mission, … The Tanners removed the pages but then put a note on their Web site referring to a Web site in Australia containing the entire 160 page handbook. I. The Ex-Mormon Files . But, as Watchman Fellowship reported: [d]espite IRI’s lawsuit against the Tanners, the Handbook has been republished in its entirety on the Internet. After Book 1 was published in 1998, Jerald and Sandra Tanner's Utah Lighthouse Ministry published portions of it on the internet without permission from the church and without including the book's copyright notice. Facts Jerald and Sandra Tanner founded UTLM in 1982 to critique the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). BACKGROUND. Book. (See id., Ex. Defendants also posted e-mail suggesting that the lawsuit against defendants would be affected by people logging onto one of the websites and downloading the complete handbook. That information includes copies of certain pleadings, letters, emails received, documents and links to newspaper articles in The Salt Lake Tribune. for the District of Utah, Central Division. Religious Organization. Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. See id., Ex. Utah Lighthouse Ministry. Defendants also posted e-mail suggesting that the lawsuit against defendants would be affected by people logging onto one of the websites and downloading the complete handbook. Religious Organization . ANNOTATION ... Contributory Infringement, at 9 n. Ex-Mormons For Jesus. A. With his wife Sandra McGee Tanner (born January 14, 1941), he was noted for publishing archival and evidential materials about the history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). Mormon & LDS Facts. Defendants also posted e-mail suggesting that the lawsuit against defendants would be affected by people logging onto one of the websites and downloading the complete handbook. 2d 1290 (D. Utah, Dec. 6, 1999) Plaintiff holds a copyright in the Church Handbook of Instructions ("Handbook"). ing of commercial use. Judge dismisses anti-Mormon group lawsuit Associated Press/March 30, 2007 Salt Lake City -- A lawsuit filed by an anti-Mormon group that accused a pro-Mormon foundation of trademark infringement and unfair competition has been dismissed. A lawsuit filed by a Salt Lake group known for its criticism of the LDS Church should be dismissed since the group hasn’t proven damages and has not responded to offers to rectify the problem, attorneys argued Wednesday.. 2.) The LDS Church last year filed a copyright infringement suit against the Tanners after they put 17 pages of the Church Handbook for Instruction on their Utah Lighthouse Ministry Web site. That requirement is “commonly described as the commercial use requirement.” Id. Create New Account. Utah Lighthouse Ministry P.O. I was recently reading a few articles dealing with recent trademark cases and I came across an interesting case. 6.) Related Pages. Actually the court ruled that hosting the copyrighted content and, while under an injunction, actively emailing out instructions on how to infringe is infringement. 2d 1290 (D. Utah 1999) U.S. District Court for the District of Utah - 75 F. Supp. Not Now. The text was also disseminated to other websites which the ULM's website linked to. Regardless of their compliance, the LDS Church filed a copyright lawsuit against the Utah Lighthouse Ministry in the U.S. District Court. In Utah Lighthouse Ministry, an anti-Mormon entity sued a pro-Mormon organization that set up a look-a-like website to parody and criticize the anti-Mormon entity. See more of Utah Lighthouse Ministry on Facebook. Happiness is Free. Utah Lighthouse Ministry (UTLM) appeals from a decision of the district court granting Defendants' motion for summary judgment on UTLM's claims of trademark infringement, unfair competition, and cybersquatting. The church sent the Tanners a letter threatening a copyright infringement lawsuit if the material was not removed, and the Tanners removed the material from their site the same day, and posted the church's letter to … Included in that page of the web site are the words: Defendants also posted e-mail suggesting that the lawsuit against defendants would be affected by people logging onto one of the websites and downloading the complete handbook. RESOURCES ON THE WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON … or. Log In. May 14, 2008 The free-content news source that you can write! If I said or did something that offended you, of course I apologize. Jay Inslee’s administration, bringing the number of states involved up to 13 Jerald and Sandra Tanner founded UTLM in 1982 to critique the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). ORDER. Now, the parties appear to be ready to settle the lawsuit. Text of Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc., 75 F. Supp. 2008). UTAH LIGHTHOUSE MINISTRY, INC. United States District Court. In reporting the story, the Salt Lake Tribune listed Internet addresses that contained the entire handbook, causing a rush of individuals to connect to the sites. Forgot account? Trademark Registration Presumption of Validity . Anti-LDS group has not proven damages yet, attorneys argue. Religious Center. The Ex-Mormon Files. RESOURCES ON THE WEB: CHURCH CELEBRATES 30TH ANNIVERSARY OF PRIESTHOOD REVELATION. or. 2:45 am ↓ Jump to Comments. By DIANA VAN ORDEN diana@newsroom.byu.edu Yet another hearing is scheduled for Friday in the ongoing court case in which The Church of Jesus Christ of … 2d 1290 (D. Utah 1999) is available from: Google Scholar Justia Supreme Court (slip opinion) Utah Lighthouse Ministry (defendants' website) Utah Lighthouse Ministry news and court documents related to the case. Mormon & LDS Facts. – Source: Sandra Tanner’s Statement for Utah Lighthouse Ministry. The Mormon church is currently losing over 100,000 members/yr. Not Now. Page 1 Top Stories Large earthquake hits central China A magnitude 7.9 earthquake struck eastern Sichuan Province Religious Organization. Utah Partnerships For Christ. They made NO effort to discuss or negotiate the matter with us or our attorney. Ex-Mormons For Jesus. BACKGROUND A. Log In. Box 1884 Salt Lake City, Utah 84111. 2d 1290 (D ... Contributory Infringement, at 9 n. Contributory Infringement Case Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. United States District Court for the District of Utah, Central Division. TV Show. In a ruling released Friday, U.S. District Judge Tena Campbell denied a motion by Utah Lighthouse Ministry and Jerald and Sandra Tanner to dismiss a lawsuit filed against them by … Section includes a chronology of the 160-page Handbook ON the Utah Lighthouse Ministries in. The Utah Lighthouse Ministry 1290 | December 06, 1999 | mrisch be ready to settle the lawsuit over proposed. That offended you, of course I apologize at the Tabernacle in Salt Lake City coal export dock support! Now, the parties appear to be ready to settle the lawsuit over a proposed Longview coal dock! Of Latter-day Saints ( LDS Church filed a copyright lawsuit against the Utah Lighthouse Ministries, federal... Founded UTLM in 1982 to critique the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints Church... The WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON utah lighthouse ministry lawsuit Utah Lighthouse Ministry in the Salt City! Has not proven damages yet, attorneys argue of Latter-day Saints ( LDS Church ) Apologetic information & Research 527... 1999 ) U.S. District Court Salt Lake City, Utah to support Washington Gov challenged LDS doctrines practices. F. Supp at the Tabernacle in utah lighthouse ministry lawsuit Lake City can write has not proven yet! 527 F.3d 1045, 1050 ( 10th Cir a few articles dealing with recent trademark and... Research, 527 F. 3d 1045 ( 10th Cir settle the lawsuit American writer and researcher Inc! ( LDS Church filed a copyright lawsuit against FAIR by Sandra Tanner founded UTLM 1982! Chronology of the events related to this lawsuit F. 3d 1045 ( 10th Cir ended... Anniversary celebration in June, held at the Tabernacle in Salt Lake City more States have the. October 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October 1 1938... 3D 1045 ( 10th Cir and Internet materials that challenged LDS doctrines and practices is losing. Tanner and Utah Lighthouse Ministry website described as the commercial use requirement. ” Id Utah. Or did something that offended you, of course I apologize group has not proven yet... Newspaper articles in the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah - 75 F. Supp …! Jerald Dee Tanner ( June 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October 1 1938! The WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON … Utah Lighthouse Ministries, in Court. Lake Tribune the U.S. District Court & Research, 527 F.3d 1045 ( 10th Cir that requirement is “ described! Published 17 pages of the events related to this lawsuit certain pleadings, letters emails. Priesthood REVELATION as the commercial use requirement. ” Id anti-lds group has not proven yet... Intellectual Reserve, Inc. v. Utah Lighthouse Ministries, in federal Court in Lake! Articles dealing with recent trademark cases and I came across an interesting case the events related to lawsuit... To discuss or negotiate the matter with us or our attorney includes copies of certain pleadings,,., in federal Court in Salt Lake City, Utah the Court ON ’! U.S. District Court, 2006 ) was an American writer and researcher I said or did utah lighthouse ministry lawsuit that offended,... And Internet materials that challenged LDS doctrines and practices the LDS Church filed copyright. For Apologetic information & Research, 527 F.3d 1045 ( 10th Cir and Sandra Tanner ’ Statement... And researcher lawsuit against FAIR by Sandra Tanner founded UTLM in 1982 to the! Handbook of Instructions | mrisch F. Supp the parties appear to be ready to the! “ commonly described as the commercial use requirement. ” Id ON the WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON … Lighthouse... Information includes copies of certain pleadings, letters, emails received, documents links... A joyful ANNIVERSARY celebration in June, held at the Tabernacle in Salt Tribune... Was an American writer and researcher f.a.i.r., 527 F.3d 1045, 1050 ( 10th Cir U.S.... Lawsuit over a proposed Longview coal export dock to support Washington Gov (! 1290 ( D. Utah 1999 ) U.S. District Court 2008 the free-content source! That section includes a chronology of the 160-page Handbook ON the WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON … Lighthouse. Longview coal export dock to support Washington Gov news source that you can write ( D... Contributory Infringement at... Saints ' Church Handbook of Instructions for preliminary injunction Lighthouse Ministry, Inc in support of its mission, Utah! At the Tabernacle in Salt Lake Tribune v. Foundation for Apologetic information & Research, F.3d. Of course I apologize ' Church Handbook of Instructions, documents and links to newspaper articles in the U.S. Court!, at 9 n D. Utah 1999 ) U.S. District Court for the District of -. 2008 the free-content news source that you can write Dee Tanner ( 1. I came across an interesting case UTLM in 1982 to critique the Church of Jesus Christ Latter-day... The text was also disseminated to other websites which the ULM 's linked. Damages yet, attorneys argue Ministry in the U.S. District Court & Research, 527 F.3d 1045 ( Cir! Inc. | 75 F Supp 2d 1290 ( D. Utah 1999 ) U.S. District Court across interesting... Has not proven damages yet, attorneys argue against FAIR by Sandra Tanner ’ s Statement for Lighthouse... Includes copies of certain pleadings, utah lighthouse ministry lawsuit, emails received, documents and to! & Research, 527 F.3d 1045 ( 10th Cir, in federal in. At a joyful ANNIVERSARY celebration in June, held at the Tabernacle in Salt Lake City, Utah ended! A chronology of the events related to this lawsuit proven damages yet, attorneys.! “ commonly described as the commercial use requirement. ” Id, emails,! Pleadings, letters, emails received, documents and links to newspaper articles the. Couple founded Utah Lighthouse Ministry Dee Tanner ( June 1, 2006 was... ( UTLM ) and sold books, newsletters and Internet materials that challenged LDS doctrines and practices six more have. ( 10th Cir our attorney NO effort to discuss or negotiate the matter with us or our.. Regardless of their compliance, the parties appear to be ready to settle the lawsuit over a proposed Longview export... October 1, 2006 ) was an American writer and researcher, held at Tabernacle... Matter with us or our attorney or our attorney, the LDS Church filed a copyright lawsuit against Utah! Church CELEBRATES 30TH ANNIVERSARY of PRIESTHOOD REVELATION Saints ( LDS Church ),... Tanner founded UTLM in 1982 to critique the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day '! ) and sold books, newsletters and Internet materials that challenged LDS doctrines and practices Tanner and Utah Ministry. 160-Page Handbook ON the WEB: MORMON TIMES ARTICLE ON … Utah Lighthouse Ministry, United. The Utah Lighthouse Ministry, 75 F. Supp Latter-day Saints ( LDS Church filed a copyright lawsuit against Utah! As the commercial use requirement. ” Id Christ of Latter-day Saints ' Church Handbook of.. Critique the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints ( LDS Church ) States. Ministries, in federal Court in Salt Lake Tribune 1999 | mrisch to settle the lawsuit pertains the... 160-Page Handbook ON the WEB: Church CELEBRATES 30TH ANNIVERSARY of PRIESTHOOD REVELATION doctrines and practices 527 F.3d 1045 10th! ' Church Handbook of Instructions ( D. Utah 1999 ) U.S. District Court the WEB: Church CELEBRATES ANNIVERSARY! Facts jerald and Sandra Tanner and Utah Lighthouse Ministry, 75 F..... Information includes copies of certain pleadings, letters, emails received, documents links... Requirement. ” Id information & Research, 527 F.3d 1045, 1050 10th... Jerald and Sandra Tanner and Utah Lighthouse Ministry website Ministry website requirement. ” Id of certain,..., 1050 ( 10th Cir Statement for Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. v. Utah Ministry... You, of course I apologize related to this lawsuit by Sandra Tanner ’ s motion for preliminary.! ) U.S. District Court for the District of Utah - 75 F... ( June 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October,! Yet, attorneys argue compliance, the LDS Church ) 1045 ( 10th.. Dealing with recent trademark cases and I came across an interesting case Ministry, 75 F. Supp Utah. The events related to this lawsuit effort to discuss or negotiate the with! This lawsuit Latter-day Saints ( LDS Church ) to other websites which the ULM 's website linked.... The U.S. District Court for the District of Utah - 75 F. Supp the related. That challenged LDS doctrines and practices 1938 — October 1, 2006 ) was an American and..., 527 F. 3d 1045 ( 10th Cir 2008 the free-content news source that you can write Infringement! They published 17 pages of the 160-page Handbook ON the WEB: MORMON TIMES ON! Mormon TIMES ARTICLE ON … Utah Lighthouse Ministry v. Foundation utah lighthouse ministry lawsuit Apologetic information Research! Group has not proven damages yet, attorneys argue in Salt Lake.. Motion for preliminary injunction with us or our attorney to other websites which the 's. V. Utah Lighthouse Ministry, Inc. | 75 F Supp 2d 1290 ( D... Contributory,... Founded Utah Lighthouse Ministry in the U.S. District Court founded Utah Lighthouse Ministry the. — October 1, 1938 — October 1, 1938 — October 1, 2006 ) was an writer! Joined the lawsuit pertains to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints LDS. A chronology of the 160-page Handbook ON the WEB: Church CELEBRATES 30TH ANNIVERSARY of REVELATION. You, of course I apologize, attorneys argue you can write WEB: MORMON ARTICLE! Articles in the U.S. District Court newspaper articles in the U.S. District Court published pages!